Crossville Chronicle, Crossville, TN

Area News

May 9, 2013

Meth case search upheld; 3 to face trial

'Knock and talk' search ruled legal

CROSSVILLE — Three Cumberland Countians are headed for an Aug. 15 trial date on charges of initiation of the process to manufacture methamphetamine after a Criminal Court judge upheld a 'knock and talk' consent to search granted by one of the defendants.

In a hearing last week, Cumberland County Sheriff's Investigator Jeff Slayton was the only witness to testify during the lengthy hearing, and in the end, the only evidence Judge Leon Burns had to consider was Slayton's remembrance of the events that took place just over a year ago.

Defendants in the case are Cindy Ann and Ronald Dale Dillaha and are represented by Randal Boston. Scott Michael Emerson is represented by Jimmy Smith. The state's case was presented by Assistant District Attorney Caroline Knight.

A fourth defendant has not been arrested on the indictment and remains on the run.

Boston and Smith filed motions have the search ruled illegal and have any evidence seized as a result of that search ruled inadmissible as a result.

The main issue was whether Cindy Dillaha had authority to grant permission to search the home she shared with her husband, and with Emerson, who had spent the night prior to the search in the residence as a guest.

Slayton is a member of the sheriff's department's CNET (Criminal Nuisance Enforcement Team), a group of about half a dozen deputies trained to focus on high crime areas. Slayton also has training as an advanced methamphetamine cleanup technician, in addition to being an investigator with the department.

On April 19, 2012, Slayton, Sgt. Jason Elmore, K-9 Deputy Danny Stone and Deputy David Moore went to the Dillaha's 94 Layken Dr. address in response to anonymous telephone and email complaints concerning suspicious traffic at the residence.

He testified that he went to the residence for a 'knock and talk' contact, during which officers make contact with residents who live in homes where complaints have been made, tell the resident what the complaints are, and ask for permission to search the residence to confirm and put to rest the information the department has received.

Cindy Dillaha answered the door and Slayton testified that he told her, "Most of the time we don't find anything, but sometimes we do."

After talking with Dillaha at the front door, officers were granted permission to search. However, Slayton said a rather large dog was present and Dillaha was asked to have the dog put in a safe area. One of the occupants took the dog outside at which time he was spotted by Stone dropping something by a backyard fence.

Later officers recovered syringes and other drug-related contraband.

Slayton testified that a search of the entire house was conducted, and that Emerson was found in one bedroom, sitting on a bed. In a dresser hidden behind clothes, deputies found three clear, plastic bottles. One of the bottles was what the investigator described as a "one-pot" meth lab. Other bottles contained components relating to clandestine meth lab production.

In other areas items associated with meth manufacturing were seized, and in a bathroom off the Dillaha's bedroom, syringes were recovered.

When asked by Knight if anyone objected to the search, Slayton responded, "I was never asked to stop the search."

Under cross examination, Smith asked Slayton why he did not get a consent to search document signed by the Dillahas or by Emerson. Slayton responded that he had received permission from Cindy Dillaha.

Boston asked if it was routine to search a house "based on emails and anonymous phone calls." Slayton responded that many tips come to the department that way.

The four were taken to the Justice Center but were not charged at the time. Instead, information about the search and seizure was presented to a grand jury and the four were indicted last year.

No defense witnesses were called, and instead, Boston and Smith relied on case law they presented to forward their position, and oral arguments.

In her argument, Knight argued that not only was permission to search granted, but a reasonable search took place and that the search was proper. She added, "Emerson lacked standing to challenge the search because he was a guest. There is no proof he received mail at the residence, had a house key."

Smith countered that he believed his client did have standing to challenge the search and said the investigators should have been professional enough to get a consent to search document signed. "It was an unreasonable search," he said.

Smith added that he believed Cindy Dillaha did not have the power to waive her husband's interest when she granted the search.

Burns found that there was no testimony disputing Slayton's statement that Cindy Dillaha granted permission to search. The judge added that the search was carried out "without objection" or complaint, and therefore was a legal search.

Although the trial is set for Aug. 15, there is a possibility that another date for hearing additional motions will be set at a later time.

1
Text Only
Area News
  • Cruikshank cattle called Cumberland County home

    Sept. 23, 1903, Chronicle reports, “The members of the Christian Church here are preparing to erect a church building on the corner lot facing Webb Avenue and the Rockwood Road. Dr. Thomas Snodgrass owned a block of lots near the Academy (Webster Academy) and before he died made the offer of a corner lot for the building of a Christian Church.

    August 1, 2014

  • Steak and Potatoes Field Day set Aug. 5

    The annual Steak and Potatoes Field Day, sponsored by the University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, will once again showcase the research and outreach activities at UT’s Plateau AgResearch and Education Center.

    August 1, 2014

  • Man dies while in custody

    The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation is investigating the death of a man who died while in custody of local law enforcement.

    August 1, 2014

  • Hole in one highlights day one of Women's Open

    Haverly Harrold of Johnson City, TN, recorded a hole-in-one on the par 3, 11th hole in the first day of play at the 16th annual Golf Capital of Tennessee Women's Open at Stonehenge Golf Club Thursday.

    August 1, 2014

  • BOE recognizes city.jpg City praised by school officials

    The Cumberland County Board of Education, represented by Director of Schools Donald Andrews, right, recognized the city of Crossville, represented by City Manager David Rutherford, left, and Crossville Mayor J.H. Graham III, center, at its July 24 meeting with a certificate of appreciation for the city’s continued support of education in Cumberland County.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Report of missing child turns out false; one charged

    A man living in Crossville set off a major search by law enforcement officers and about 40 employees of a retail store after he reported a small child missing. He later recanted and has now been charged with a misdemeanor charge.

    July 31, 2014

  • tourism-granville.jpg Tourism talk dominates roundtable meeting

    Tourism is big business in Cumberland County and the state of Tennessee.
    Tennessee state officials visited the Crossville-Cumberland County Chamber of Commerce and provided a wealth of information for a roundtable discussion County Mayor Kenneth Carey Jr. organized.

    July 31, 2014 2 Photos

  • School system closes budget with more in reserves than planned

    The school system is going to end the year with a little more in its reserves than originally thought, Bob Scarbrough, transportation/maintenance supervisor and acting CFO, at the July 24 meeting of the Cumberland County Board of Education.
    "We believe there will be $4.7 million in the fund balance, which is quite a bit better than anticipated," Scarbrough said.

    July 31, 2014

  • Investigation into assault continues

    A Sparta Hwy. man found with lacerations to the back of the head told Cumberland County sheriff's deputies he was assaulted at a residence on Hwy. 70 N, but doesn't know why.

    July 31, 2014

  • Theft, arson of storage shed reported

    Someone broke into a storage shed and stole several items and, to add insult to injury, set the storage building on fire, according to a Cumberland County Sheriff's Department report.

    July 31, 2014

Marketplace Marquee
Parade
Must Read
Section Teases
Seasonal Content
AP Video
Renewed Violence Taking Toll on Gaza Residents 2 Americans Detained in North Korea Seek Help US Employers Add 209K Jobs, Rate 6.2 Pct House GOP Optimistic About New Border Bill Gaza Truce Unravels; Israel, Hamas Trade Blame Raw: Tunisia Closes Borders With Libya Four Rescued From Crashed Plane Couple Channel Grief Into Soldiers' Retreat WWI Aviation Still Alive at Aerodrome in NY Raw: Rescuers at Taiwan Explosion Scene Raw: Woman Who Faced Death Over Faith in N.H. Clinton Before 9-11: Could Have Killed Bin Laden Netanyahu Vows to Destroy Hamas Tunnels Obama Slams Republicans Over Lawsuit House Leaders Trade Blame for Inaction
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Weather Radar
2014 Readers' Choice
Graduation 2014