Crossville Chronicle, Crossville, TN

Area News

March 29, 2013

Pocket DNA conviction under appeal

Bruff opts to defend self in series of hearings

CROSSVILLE — For a case that has bounced around the court system since 2008, the end of testimony and arguments came to a less than dramatic halt. Demanding his right to represent himself, Howard G. Bruff, convicted of the March 2004 murder of Kevin Hixson, simply said last Friday, "I can't even think anymore ... your honor, I'm done."

The life of the appeal included months of delays, two long days of testimony and a heated and lively exchange between Bruff and his lawyer during the trial, Tom Beesley, who said from the witness stand, "One reason you are where you are is because you think you know more than anyone else." Beesley added that he believed Bruff has a "narcisstic personality."

Bruff became the first person in Tennessee convicted on DNA evidence taken from inside the pocket of a victim. A Cumberland County jury convicted him of first-degree murder, felony murder and especially aggravated robbery after deliberating three hours.

The jury also assessed a $50,000 fine for the robbery conviction, and trial judge Lillie Ann Sells merged the two murder convictions into one, handing down a life sentence. In Tennessee, with good time figured in, that equates to about 51 years in prison.

Bruff was convicted of shooting Kevin Shawn Hixson, 32, Lancer Dr., Lake Tansi, once in the back off the head as the victim leaned over a television while working on a satellite system, and then once again in the head "execution style," evidence during trial showed.

Investigators believed robbery was the motive, and asked the TBI forensics lab in Nashville to test the victim's jean pockets for DNA. The DNA found inside the pocket could only be matched to Bruff, the forensic scientist testified at trial.

Also introduced during the trial was testimony that Bruff had told his mother that Hixson had been shot in the back of the head before investigators released that information to the news media.

The defendant insisted on representing himself, against the repeated advice of Judge Leon Burns, and at first rejected any assistance from an attorney, opting to put his one chance at getting his conviction based on ineffective counsel thrown out.

He complained that court appointed attorney Kevin Bryant would not ask all the questions he wanted asked, so he invoked his constitutional right to represent himself, contrary to President Abraham Lincoln's famous quote about acting as one's own attorney.

Bruff, with assistance of an inmate in the Tennessee prison system, filed a voluminous petition for a new trial based on a claim that his trial lawyer was ineffective, blaming Beesley for his conviction.

The filing listed 18 original arguments backing that claim — some repetitive — and additional briefs added other claims. The first motion for new trial was filed in May of 2008. It was not until last year that court appearances to hear arguments on the motions began.

Filings and state responses followed, setting the stage for testimony and oral arguments in court which began on July 27. It was at that time that Bruff announced he no longer wanted Bryant to represent him.

"You only get one bite of the apple," Judge Leon Burns told Bruff, while advising him to reconsider his decision to act as his own attorney.

Bruff rejected the judge's advice, stating the questions he wanted asked "are important to my case ... this is my only shot at proving what I have to prove in my case."

Bryant had advised Bruff some of the 19 witnesses he had called, and questions he wanted asked, had no value on proving whether Beesley had been ineffective.

Bruff's biggest complaint was that Beesley never acted as an investigator and questioned potential witnesses, that he did not pursue alternate theories on who could have committed the murder, and that he did not properly challenge the DNA evidence used against him.

Beesley countered that the state provided him a private investigator who did interview witnesses and potential witnesses, and that it was not his job to do the investigator's work.

Several witnesses were called on July 27, but Bruff's intent seemed focused more on a claim that one man had boasted he had killed Hixson, and that another man had a motive and had threatened Hixson shortly before his death.

James Phillips was called by Bruff as a witness, but denied he had ever said he had killed Hixson. "I never killed nobody," Phillips testified. "That kid was one of my friends."

The other, Mike Stone, testified that he did call Hixson shortly before Hixson's death and told him he had learned Hixson had sold drugs to his then girlfriend, and that if he thought he was going to get paid, "he was out of luck." Stone said he did use profanity during the phone call because he was angry over the discovery, but that he had never threatened him.

Stone testified last Friday that he learned of Hixson's death while reading the Chronicle on a Sunday morning. He said he called Sheriff Butch Burgess to report making the phone call, and was referred to TBI Special Agent Tommy Calahan to whom he gave a statement.

Bruff chastised Beesley for not pursuing the two men as possible suspects in the case, but Beesley countered that Phillips has always denied making the statement and that the only witness saying he made the statement, was a person with a substantial criminal record.

As for not calling Stone as a witness during the trial, Beesley testified that he had read the TBI interview and saw no reason to pursue that angle. There was no advantage to Bruff's defense of pursuing that theory, Beesley testified.

Bruff attacked the state forensic scientist for only using one cotton swab to seek DNA trace evidence from all four pockets. The scientist should have used four swabs — one for each pocket, Bruff argued.

On this issue, Burns questioned out loud whether it really mattered what pocket the DNA came from. The issue was, Bruff's DNA was found in a pocket of a dead man's jeans, proving he was there.

While the state's theory was that Bruff's DNA was left behind when he reached into Hixson's pocket to steal money after the slaying, Bruff claimed he reached into Hixson's pocket on another occasion to retrieve an item because Hixson could not.

Another issue raised by Bruff was his complaint that Deputy District Attorney General Gary McKenzie made "voluminous misstatements of facts" during closing arguments, without Beesley objecting.

Last Friday McKenzie told Burns there existed "no evidence of any irregularities" and that it didn't really matter how many swabs were used to take DNA samples. What mattered was that Bruff's DNA was the only DNA found.

"He got a great defense and the Court of Appeals stated as much," McKenzie argued.

When it came time for Bruff to close, he took a few minutes to enter court records and other documents into the record, or make them part of his case for a new trial, but then abruptly ended the day.

Burns announced he would take the case under advisement and at some point issue a written, and/or oral, ruling on the motions. He said he was undecided as to whether he would do so in open court, or in a filing.

The case is expected to be appealed to the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals for review.

Text Only
Area News
  • Summer winding down in Tennessee

    July 25, 2014

  • Celebrating a year of writing our area's history

    Now that this column has passed its first birthday, I’d like to send thanks to those of you from our county and around the country who have sent messages and questions about things you’ve read in the Uncle Gib section. It is hard to cover many of these events in 500 words, and I try not go cover the same event more than three weeks. Research must be cut way down, and the most interesting information on each subject included.

    July 25, 2014

  • IMG_1806.jpg Celebrate Farmers Market Week Aug. 3-9

    Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack has declared August 3 through 9, 2014, “National Farmers Market Week.” Throughout the week, USDA will celebrate the nation’s thousands of farmers markets, farmers who make them possible and the communities that host them.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Ayers2.jpg County OKs resolution for CMC/Covenant refinance deal

    Cumberland County commissioners passed a resolution Monday evening giving its approval for Covenant Health to refund its bonds to refinance $40 million for Cumberland Medical Center.
    The request was made by Covenant Health, a Tennessee nonprofit corporation which now operates Cumberland Medical Center.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Plea includes ban from all Wal-Mart stores

    A Crossville man who was facing two counts of theft of more than $500, relating to shoplifting incidents at the Crossville Wal-mart, has entered a guilty plea, and part of his sentence is being banned from all Wal-Mart stores.

    July 24, 2014

  • Forgery charges net six months in jail

    A Crossville woman already on parole because of a felony theft conviction has pleaded guilty to two felony counts relating to forged checks and received a split sentence with six months to be serve in jail.

    July 24, 2014

  • Unfunded mandates a challenge for schools

    Director of Schools Donald Andrews has expressed local concerns regarding unfunded state mandates in education to Gov. Bill Haslam in an informal meeting between the governor and area administrators and teachers.

    July 24, 2014

  • IMG_3745.jpg Vote early to avoid delays

    Cumberland County Election Administrator Suzanne Smith is encouraging Cumberland County voters to take advantage of the early voting period, which continues through Aug. 2 at the Election Commission Office at 2 S. Main St.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • state park boat dock.jpg Showcase of driving tours set today at Cumberland Mountain

    Discover the hidden gems of The Promised Land and Pie in the Sky Trails during the showcase 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. Friday, at Cumberland Mountain State Park. This special event is free and open to the public.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • waterfest2013.jpg Get on the water this weekend

    Volunteers from the Tennessee Scenic Rivers Association offer basic instruction for kayakers at the 2013 Waterfest. This year’s event is set for Saturday at Meadow Park Lake from 2 to 8 p.m. There will be activities for the whole family, with food, exhibits, kids games, live music and water activities, with TSRA instructors offering rides on canoes, kayaks and sit-on-top kayaks. There will also be pontoon tours of Meadow Park Lake from 3 to 7 p.m., offering a chance to look for wildlife. The University of Tennessee Concrete Canoe Team will be demonstrating their craft, as well, at 2:30 p.m.

    July 23, 2014 1 Photo 1 Link

Marketplace Marquee
Must Read
Section Teases
Seasonal Content
AP Video
Gaza Residents Mourn Dead Amid Airstrikes Raw: Deadly Tornado Hits Virginia Campground Ohio State Marching Band Chief Fired After Probe Raw: Big Rig Stuck in Illinois Swamp Cumberbatch Brings 'Penguins' to Comic-Con Raw: Air Algerie Crash Site in Mali Power to Be Restored After Wash. Wildfire Crashed Air Algerie Plane Found in Mali Israel Mulls Ceasefire Amid Gaza Offensive In Case of Fire, Oxygen Masks for Pets Mobile App Gives Tour of Battle of Atlanta Sites Anti-violence Advocate Killed, but Not Silenced. Dempsey: Putin May Light Fire and Lose Control Arizona Prison Chief: Execution Wasn't Botched Calif. Police Investigate Peacock Shooting Death Raw: Protesters, Soldiers Clash in West Bank Police: Doctor Who Shot Gunman 'Saved Lives' 'Modern Family' Star on Gay Athletes Coming Out MN Twins Debut Beer Vending Machine DA: Pa. Doctor Fired Back at Hospital Gunman
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Weather Radar
2014 Readers' Choice
Graduation 2014