Crossville Chronicle, Crossville, TN

Glade Sun

August 28, 2013

Scout Report: On crime and punishment

CROSSVILLE — The Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution contains three clauses and is the shortest of the amendments in the Bill of Rights. It reads as follows:

“Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”

The Eighth Amendment was based off of the 1689 English Bill of Rights. In fact, it was taken almost verbatim, with one distinct change: “That excessive bail ought not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”

The distinction lies in one operative word: “ought not be required” versus “shall not be required.” This change reflects James Madison’s insistence that the amendments be legally enforceable, not mere hortatory statements. It’s the difference between telling your child they “ought” to clean their room versus mandating that they do so …  as in “ye shall clean thine room or I shall smite thee” (rules  carry more authority in the archaic tense).

The English Bill of Rights was enacted in response to the infamously tyrannical Star Chamber. The Star Chamber originally served as a king’s council to supervise lords under Henry VII. Inevitably it grew into an oppressive tool of the crown used to destroy political opposition, generate revenue for the treasury through extraordinary fines and confiscation, and to punish disobedience to its illegal proclamations.

Punishments and fines were arbitrary, and often outside the scope of the law. Often these judgments were extremely harsh and not part of any written law; they essentially made up the rules as they went along. The results were punishments issued for cruelty and vindication rather than for the sake of justice. The English Bill of Rights made it illegal for courts to impose any punishment or fine that was unknown to the common law.

Moreover, it established an essential pillar of justice – bail. Bail is money or property paid by a defendant in a criminal case that is to be forfeited if they do not return for their trial; basically, it’s just an insurance policy. Without a bail system, courts would have no assurance that those facing charges wouldn’t just skip out at the first chance. As such, courts would have no recourse but to keep them locked up until trial, causing an undue burden. Remember, our system of justice is hinged on the premise that everyone is innocent until proven guilty. It takes time to build a case, for both the prosecution and defense teams. Often, several weeks or months, and sometimes even years pass after an initial arrest is made for the trial to conclude. During this time, the defendant would not be able to work, which would create a hardship on top of the financial burden associated with navigating the legal system. They would also miss out on important parts of their lives, such as holidays and family time. The intent of the amendment is both to enforce the presumption of innocence until guilt has been proven, as well as to permit those accused the freedom to prepare an adequate defense.

The provisions of the Eighth Amendment also demand that punishments must be fair and proportional to the crime. The “cruel and unusual punishment” clause draws the most contention. “Cruel” and “unusual” seem like such subjective terms – what one may consider such, another may not. Indeed, punishments that may have been considered commonplace 200 years ago would probably be considered barbaric by today’s society. 

On the floor of the first Congress that proposed the Eighth Amendment, Representative Livermore complained about the vagueness of the amendment’s language: “It is sometimes necessary to hang a man, villains often deserve a whipping, and perhaps having their ears cut off, but are we in the future to be prevented from inflicting those punishments because they are ‘cruel’?”

The Supreme Court has wavered on definitions over the years, often misinterpreting the original intent. In the 1958 case of Trop v Dulles, for instance, it ruled that “cruel and unusual punishment” included revoking citizenship, which it considered to be “the total destruction of the individual’s status in organized society.” The case further established that the definitions of “cruel” and “unusual” should change over time, being those punishments which offend society’s “evolving sense of decency.”

Taken in the historical context of the language, however, it is much less convoluted. As noted, the amendment was taken almost verbatim from the English Bill of Rights, which tells us these practices were prohibited because such punishments were “utterly and directly contrary to the known laws and statutes and freedom of this realm.”

The English Bill of Rights was a response to the Star Chamber, which, as discussed earlier, would make up the rules as it went along. James Madison understood “unusual” to mean outside the normal scope of the written law. The Eighth Amendment was written as a protection against the Judicial Branch more so than the Legislative Branch. On the matter of “cruelty,” again this was a check on judges. Back then, legislators had to live under the same rules that they wrote (unlike our modern “representatives”), ensuring that the proscribed punishments would not be overly harsh.

The Constitution was not written for a perfect people; if there were such a thing, laws would not be necessary. The point of the Eighth Amendment is that punishments should not be arbitrary or whimsical. It does not, in any way, preclude the death penalty. It simply means that punishments should be thoughtful, methodical and apply to everyone equally.

“In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself.” James Madison

• • •

Clinton Gill is editor of the Glade Sun. His column is published weekly. He may be reached at

Text Only
Glade Sun
  • County residents urged to vote

    Cumberland County has around 39,000 registered voters, as well as a strong reputation for voter participation.  However, as of press time on Tuesday, only 4,300 residents had taken advantage of early voting for the Aug. 7 primary and general elections. Local officials are predicting less than 50 percent of registered voters will cast their vote in the 14 days of early voting, plus election day. Only 23 percent of registered county voters participated in the May elections.

    July 30, 2014

  • Board amends by-laws

    At the July meeting of the Fairfield Glade Community Club, the board of directors approved a vote to amend the club's bylaws regarding uncontested elections of board members, effectively declaring Bob Diller and Steven Smith new board members.

    July 30, 2014

  • Naiad Kuhlman.jpg Senior olympian on the run for good health

    No one can get away with telling Naiad Kuhlman of Crossville that age is a barrier to exercise. The avid runner, personal trainer and instructor at Cumberland Medical Center’s Wellness Complex at Fairfield Glade won’t buy the excuse.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Enjoying nature.jpg Get your mink coat on the road

    It is interesting what animals you see crossing the roads sometimes. When animals cross roads, you can get a look at them, that wouldn't be possible if they stayed inside the cover of trees or grass. Sometimes, it is just a fleeting glance and you aren't sure what you saw. When you go into the woods looking for animals, they usually hide or leave the area before you even know they are around. But, roads are wide open with no cover. Also, most mammals are nocturnal, so they are out when we aren't. Anytime that I am on a two-lane road at night, I am always watching intently for wildlife in the headlights.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Read the latest edition of "The Bulletin"

    The Crossville Chronicle-Glade Sun also publishes a newsletter called "The Bulletin" in which you'll find a schedule of Glade activities and events, a restaurant and dining guide, golf information, and even tour schedules. Click here for the latest PDF edition of "The Bulletin."

    April 21, 2010 1 Link

  • Patches of Life: The replacement years

    I need a new refrigerator. There are some other things on order too as we seem to be in the replacement year of our life. Everything from the light bulbs to the computer seemed to agree that this is the year of replacement.

    July 30, 2014

  • Abacus Column: Tennessee the third most corrupt state in the U.S.?

    According to a recent article in Time magazine, Tennessee is ranked third among U.S. States in political corruption. I am not sure how they measure such crime in order to make such a charge. Does some purveyor of statistics identify the number of elected officials proved guilty in a court of law; or merely charged with corruption?

    July 30, 2014

  • A Time 4 Paws celebrates pet adoption after 3 1/2 years

    Three and a half years ago, a local no-kill animal welfare organization known as A Time 4 Paws (AT4P) received an important email. A Nashville animal shelter volunteer asked if AT4P could take two severely abused English Pointer mixes. The email said they didn't want to take back two dogs they had placed in foster care for fear they would have to kill them.

    July 30, 2014

  • A Time 4 Paws collecting shoes to help Soles4Souls in fight against global poverty

    Attention anyone with a closet! Those shoes no longer wanted are desperately needed to fight the human tragedy of global poverty.
    That’s the message being delivered by A Time 4 Paws, which has launched an ongoing drive to collect shoes to help the poor. Used and new shoes can be dropped off at A Time 4 Paws in Crossville and can be left in the blue recycling bin outside labeled Soles4Souls.

    July 30, 2014

  • FFG Treasure Hunt set for Sept. 5

    The 2014 Fairfield Glade Treasure Hunt is set for Friday, Sept. 5. This has always been a fun evening for those who enjoy puzzle solving, figuring out clues or just having a good time.

    July 30, 2014

Marketplace Marquee
Must Read
Section Teases
Seasonal Content
AP Video
Obama Chides House GOP for Pursuing Lawsuit New Bill Aims to Curb Sexual Assault on Campus Russia Counts Cost of New US, EU Sanctions 3Doodler Bring 3-D Printing to Your Hand Six PA Cops Indicted for Robbing Drug Dealers Britain Testing Driverless Cars on Roadways Raw: Thousands Flocking to German Crop Circle At Least 20 Chikungunya Cases in New Jersey Raw: Obama Eats Ribs in Kansas City In Virginia, the Rise of a New Space Coast Raw: Otters Enjoy Water Slides at Japan Zoo NCAA Settles Head-injury Suit, Will Change Rules Raw: Japanese Soldiers Storm Beach in Exercises Raw: Weapons Fire Hits UN School in Gaza Raw: Rocket Launches Into Space With Cargo Ship Broken Water Main Floods UCLA Two Women Narrowly Avoid Being Hit by Train Crayola Announces Family Attraction in Orlando
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Weather Radar
2014 Readers' Choice
Graduation 2014